The first section sets the basic setting for the inquiry by asserting the weight of distinguishing between mathematical and philosophical certainty. This distinction is central to understanding the nature of knowledge in both natural theology and morality, Kant argues. He then proceeds to study the nature of metaphysical certainty, giving attention to the differences between philosophical and mathematical reasoning. This analysis provides a structure for understanding the principles of natural theology and morality, showing the difficulties and details involved in philosophical reasoning compared to the more concrete and defined realm of mathematics. In later parts of the treatise, the nature of metaphysical certainty is studied in depth, focusing on the principles of natural theology. The discussion includes a study of concepts such as existence, necessity, and the attributes of a divine being, providing a philosophical foundation for arguments about the existence and nature of God. The final sections of the book are devoted to morality, analyzing the principles that underlie moral reasoning and obligation. Kant studies the conceptual foundations of moral obligations, the nature of ethical principles, and the relationship between moral philosophy and practical decision making.
This work responded to a 1763 prize competition by the Berlin Royal Academy asking whether metaphysical principles could achieve the same certainty as mathematical truths, earning Kant second place behind Moses Mendelssohn's winning submission yet establishing his reputation as a notable popular author. Kant's central argument was that mathematics and philosophy employ at base different methods: mathematics constructs its concepts synthetically by combining given magnitudes through definitions that create their objects, while philosophy must work analytically from confused given concepts toward distinctness without the luxury of arbitrary stipulation. The essay claimed that metaphysics cannot imitate mathematical procedure because philosophical concepts like existence, substance, or space arrive already given in experience and must be clarified through patient analysis rather than constructed through definition, making philosophical certainty different in kind though not inferior to mathematical demonstration. Drawing on Newton to distinguish between mathematical and philosophical method and on Hutcheson to argue that moral obligation rests on "an unanalyzable feeling of the good" rather than pure rational derivation from perfection, Kant departed markedly from Leibnizian Wolffian rationalism while insisting that metaphysics could still attain conviction through its own proper procedures. The treatise addressed methodological foundations that would preoccupy Kant throughout his career, foreshadowing his later critical distinction between the synthetic construction of mathematical cognition and the conceptual analysis of philosophical cognition, while his emphasis on moral feeling anticipated parts of his mature ethical theory even as he remained optimistic about metaphysical knowledge before his critical awakening.