Ending Zero Tolerance: The Crisis of Absolute School Discipline

In the era of zero tolerance, we are flooded with stories about schools issuing draconian punishments for relatively innocent behavior. One student was suspended for chewing a Pop-Tart into the shape of a gun. Another was expelled for cursing on social media. Suspension and expulsion rates have doubled over the past three decades as zero tolerance policies have become the normal response to a host of minor infractions that extend well beyond just drugs and weapons. Students from all demographic groups have suffered, but minority and special needs students have suffered the most. On average, middle and high schools suspend one out of four African American students at least once a year.

The effects of these policies are devastating. Just one suspension in the ninth grade doubles the likelihood that a student will drop out. Fifty percent of students who drop out are subsequently unemployed. Eighty percent of prisoners are high school drop outs. The risks associated with suspension and expulsion are so high that, as a practical matter, they amount to educational death penalties.

Derek Black weaves stories about individual students, lessons from social science, and the outcomes of court cases to unearth a shockingly irrational system of punishment. Ending Zero Tolerance argues for constitutional protections to check abuses in school discipline.

"A cogent, comprehensive, and creative resource." —James E. Ryan,Charles William Eliot Professor, Harvard Graduate School of Education

"Necessary reading for educators." ― Youth Today