
Cassandra T
- Flag inappropriate
- Show review history
My rating is between two stars 'it's ok' and three stars 'I like it'. My expectations for and the reality of this book led to my disappointment. The book has sections for basic sweater types, body shape, neck shape, sleeve shape, buttons and pockets, but the amount of detail is uneven. Basic concepts, such as tapering, are over-explained and more advanced concepts, like darts to shape the front and back differently, are assumed knowledge. Books like this one are so important, and I really appreciate the breadth of coverage in this book. Compared to Ann Budd's Top-Down Sweaters, there are more visual of silhouettes of the basic types and how the arm holes are shaped to explain the basic sweater construction and similar basic templates for the yoke, raglan, drop-shoulder, and set-in sleeve. Amy Herzog's patterns are all bottom-up. Also, since Amy Herzog focuses on shaping of the torso, she prefers knitting in pieces to get the right structure. Things I learned and found useful --------------------------- Superwash yarns should be knit a bit tighter. Amy describes a "poke-test" to see if you can poke part of your finger through the swatch. Using darts and moving the location of shaping for front and back can help with fit if a person's front and back are fairly different, for example a very rounded upper back. I understand the most basic types of sweaters well: yoke, raglan, drop-shoulder, and set-in sleeve. I can maybe search and find sentences about how one type morphs into say a dolman sleeve. Frustrations ------------ The organization does not really allow the book to be used as a reference because it breaks up concepts between multiple sections. It seems that the reader is supposed to pick one of the basic templates and then read it through. Because the writing is presented in a more fluid-way and dispersed across sections and sample patterns, it's hard to just go in and say, hey, I want to adjust the sleeve in this pattern and then find all the information you might need. You would need to refer to multiple sections just to learn about sleeves. There are not enough images. At one point, Amy refers the reader to go online to see what she means about button holes. There are no images. Some very basic concepts are over-explained and more advanced are not well-explained, making it unclear for whom the book is written. For example: The calculation for the slope of a line, which we learned in high school, is referred to repeatedly and described in paragraphs. The placing and calculation of darts for shaping is not explained at all. It's referenced and shown in a figure of silhouettes conceptually but without proportion or scaling information. I'm not saying the slope of a line isn't important, but it's so basic that I bet it's not a primary concern for anyone making great use of the concepts in this book... The seeming omissions of parts of explanation of shaping and fit made it seem like we are supposed to collect all of Amy Herzog's books. (I haven't read her others). Darts are one example. The explanation of adding pockets doesn't have enough pictures. Again, I can calculate decreases, but how to use the waste yarn to attach a pocket is new and a lot to figure out on one's own. What about movement? Ease is introduced and discussed at a few points, and I would like to know more about other tricks. For example, Gansey sweaters have gussets for movement. Scoping the book to not include all of these variations is not my biggest frustration, but shows the kinds of things I hoped to learn about from the book. The neck section has no photos. It just generally describes basic shapes. Nicky Epstein's Knitting Over The Edge has many collar and cuff types.
4 people found this review helpful